Butterfly valve designs have several key factors that determine their suitability for applications.
What are the different types of Butterfly Valve Designs?
1. Butterfly Valve Offset Designs
Offsets describe how the shaft and disc are positioned relative to the valve seat and body centerline. The number of offsets directly affects sealing performance, torque, wear, and service conditions.
Concentric (Zero Offset) Butterfly Valves
✅ Most basic and widely used design
Design Description
- The shaft (stem) is centered on the pipe centerline
- The disc is concentric with the seat and body
- The disc remains in continuous contact with the seat during rotation.
Sealing Principle
- Position-seated
- Tight shutoff is achieved by compressing the disc into a resilient seat
Key Characteristics
- Continuous disc-to-seat interference
- Higher friction during opening and closing
- Seat wear occurs over time due to rubbing
Typical Applications
- Water & wastewater
- Gebäudetechnik
- Fire protection
- General utility services
Why Customers Choose It
- Lowest cost
- Simple, compact design
- Excellent for low-pressure, ambient-temperature services.
Double Offset (High Performance) Butterfly Valves
✅ Step up in performance and durability
Design Description
- First offset: Shaft is offset behind the disc centerline
- Second offset: Shaft is offset from the pipe centerline
- Creates a camming action where the disc pulls away from the seat early during opening
Sealing Principle
- Position-seated with reduced friction
- Disc only contacts the seat during the final 5–7% of closure
Key Characteristics
- Lower operating torque than concentric designs
- Reduced seat wear
- Improved cycle life
- Can incorporate resilient or metal seats
Typical Applications
- Dampf
- Hydrocarbons
- Chemikalien
- Oil & gas utilities
- Power generation
Why Customers Choose It
- Higher pressure and temperature capability
- Longer service life
- Bi-directional tight shutoff
Triple Offset (Triple Eccentric) Butterfly Valves
✅ Highest-performance butterfly valve design
Design Description
- Includes the same first and second offsets as double offset designs
- Third offset: A conical, inclined sealing geometry machined into the disc and seat axis
- Disc and seat engage without rubbing during operation.
Sealing Principle
- Torque-seated
- Tight shutoff occurs through metal-to-metal wedging, not seat compression
Key Characteristics
- Zero friction between seat and seal during rotation
- Extremely low wear
- Excellent for fire-safe and emergency applications
- Enables bubble-tight shutoff at very high temperatures
Typical Applications
- Severe service oil & gas
- LNG
- Refining
- Power plants
- High-pressure, high-temperature, and cycling services
Why Customers Choose It
- Longest service life
- Fire-safe and fugitive-emission capable
- True alternative to gate, globe, and ball valves
2. Butterfly Valve Seat Design Types
The seat material determines chemical compatibility, temperature/pressure limits, leakage class, and lifecycle cost.
Resilient-Seated Butterfly Valves
✅ Most common and cost-effective
Sitzwerkstoffe
- EPDM
- NBR
- Buna-N
- FKM (Viton®)
Sealing Characteristics
- Soft elastomer provides bubble-tight shutoff
- Excellent for low-cycle and clean services
Einschränkungen
- Temperature limited by elastomer
- Not suitable for abrasive or high-temperature media
Typical Applications
- Water systems
- Gebäudetechnik
- Irrigation
- Fire protection
Polymer-Seated (PTFE / TFM / Plastic Lined)
✅ Chemical resistance focus
Seat & Lining Materials
- PTFE
- TFM
- UHMWPE
Sealing Characteristics
- Soft seat with near-universal chemical compatibility
- Low friction and low torque
Einschränkungen
- Limited pressure and temperature
- Cold flow under sustained load
Typical Applications
- Corrosive chemicals
- Acid and chlorine service
- Pharmaceutical and specialty chemicals
Metal-Seated Butterfly Valves
✅ Severe service and high temperature
Sitzwerkstoffe
- Stainless steel
- Hard-faced alloys
- Laminated metal seal rings
Sealing Characteristics
- Zero elastomers
- Designed for extreme temperature and pressure
- Typically used in double offset and triple offset designs
Einschränkungen
- Higher cost
- Torque-seated (actuation sizing becomes critical)
Typical Applications
- Dampf
- Hydrocarbon processing
- Fired heaters
- Power generation
- Fire-safe installations
Simple Comparison Table Overview
| Feature | Concentric | Doppelexzentrisch | Dreifach-exzentrisch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shaft Offsets | 0 | 2 | 3 |
| Sealing Type | Position seated | Position Seated, Reduced-interference | Torque seated |
| Sitzoptionen | Resilient | Resilient / Metal | Metal |
| Seat Wear | Higher | Moderate | Minimal |
| Temperature Capability | Niedrig | Medium–High | Very High |
| Typical Leakage | Bubble-tight | Bubble-tight | Bubble-tight (metal) |
The Challenge
Premature Failure in Utility and HVAC Systems
In standard low-pressure applications (up to 250 PSI), many butterfly valves suffer from line media seepage that corrodes the valve body or stem. Furthermore, constant contact between the disc and the seat throughout the 90-degree cycle often leads to excessive friction, causing the soft elastomer seat to wear out prematurely.
The Bray Solution: Series 30/31 Total Media Encapsulation
The Bray Series 30 (Wafer) and Series 31 (Lug) resolve these vulnerabilities through a high-strength, one-piece through-stem design and a unique "tongue-and-groove" seat. This architecture creates a primary and secondary seal that completely isolates the valve body and stem from the line media. By providing bidirectional, bubble-tight shutoff and a wide array of media-compatible elastomers, the Series 30/31 ensures zero external leakage and significantly reduced maintenance costs in municipal water, wastewater, and HVAC utilities.
High-Performance Solutions: Precision for Industrial Cycles
Friction-Induced Seat Degradation at High Pressure
Industrial processes in chemical and power plants often operate at ANSI Class 600 (1,440 PSI). At these pressures, the continuous seat rubbing found in standard valves leads to rapid seal degradation and unacceptably high operating torque, forcing frequent and costly service intervals.
The Bray Solution: McCannalok® Double Offset Performance
The Bray McCannalok High-Performance Butterfly Valve overcomes high-pressure wear with its patented dual-eccentric (double offset) stem and disc design. By offsetting the stem, the McCannalok creates a "camming" action that lifts the disc away from the seat immediately upon opening. This limits contact to only the final degrees of closure, drastically reducing torque and extending seat life beyond 100,000 cycles. With its pressure-assisted, bidirectional seal, the McCannalok is the industry benchmark for reliable, high-cycle performance in steam and corrosive chemical applications.
Severe Service Solutions: Safety in Extreme Environments
Seal Deformation Under Thermal and Pressure Extremes
Mission-critical systems—such as offshore oil platforms and petrochemical refineries—face temperatures ranging from -320°F to 1,500°F. Under these severe conditions, traditional "positional" seals can melt, deform, or fail entirely, leading to catastrophic system blowouts and safety risks.
The Bray Solution: Tri Lok® Triple Offset Torque-Seated Technology
For environments where failure is not an option, the Bray Tri Lok Triple Offset Valve provides a frictionless, metal-to-metal sealing system. Its advanced conical ellipse geometry allows the seal ring to engage the seat without interference until the exact moment of closure. Unlike standard valves, the Tri Lok is "torque-seated," utilizing mechanical force to achieve absolute zero leakage. Designed for critical isolation, the Tri Lok features a splined disc-to-stem connection that remains unaffected by thermal expansion, ensuring bi-directional safety in the most unforgiving refining and cryogenic services.
The Science of Seat Material Selection
Choosing the correct seat compound is a mandatory step. A mismatch here leads to premature swelling, chemical degradation, or complete valve failure.
EPDM: Highly resistant to polar compounds such as water, steam, bleach, and alkaline solutions. However, EPDM is entirely repellant to hydrocarbons and will fail if used with petroleum-based oils.
BUNA-N (Nitrile): An excellent general-purpose elastomer that heavily resists petroleum-based fluids, oils, fuels, and greases. It is highly vulnerable to extreme heat and provides little resistance to ozone.
PTFE (Teflon): Known for exceptional, near-universal chemical resistance and low-friction properties, making it ideal for corrosive chemical processes and sanitary applications
FAQ's
-
What is the difference between double offset and triple offset butterfly valves?
A double-offset valve uses a dual-eccentric stem design that creates a camming action to reduce seat friction, but it still relies on positional compression for sealing. A triple-offset valve adds an inclined conical seating geometry, completely eliminating friction to create a torque-seated, metal-to-metal seal capable of withstanding extreme temperatures (up to 1,500°F) and pressures.
-
When should I use a resilient-seated butterfly valve?
Resilient seated butterfly valves are the most cost-effective and optimal choice for lower-pressure (under 250 PSI), ambient-temperature applications handling clean, non-aggressive media. Common use cases include municipal water supply, standard industrial utilities, and HVAC systems.
-
Why do I use EPDM seats not work for oil based applications?
While EPDM is exceptionally durable against heat, water, acids and polar compounds, it lacks chemical compatibility with hydrocarbons. Exposing an EPDM seat to petroleum-based oils, diesel, or solvents will cause the material to rapidly degrade and fail. BUNA-N (Nitrile) is the correct seat material for petroleum applications.
-
What are common Applications for butterfly valves?
Butterfly valves can be a great isolation or basic control device for Water & Wastewater, HVAC, Chemical Processing, Oil & Gass, Power, Mining, Data Centers and the Semiconductor industry just to name a few.
-
Are Butterfly Valves Bidirectional?
Yes, most butterfly valve designs are bidirectional. There can be a preferred direction of flow for some designs but in general they can isolate flow from either direction.
-
How do I select the size of my butterfly valve.
In general for Isolation purposes the valve should match the diameter of the pipe it is installed in often referred to in inches, millimeters, NPS (net piping size) and DN (Diameter nominal). When selecting a product you should consider the Cv of the product to ensure there is enough flow through the pipeline and that it will not restrict your process flow. For sizing of a control valve use a sizing software to ensure the product offers the best range for your application needs.
Zertifiziert und bewährt
bei tausenden von Unternehmen weltweit
Die Regelarmaturenpakete von Bray werden individuell auf Ihre Prozessbedingungen zugeschnitten, um Sicherheit, Zuverlässigkeit und Leistung für Hersteller zu gewährleisten, die sich immer höheren Produktivitätsanforderungen stellen müssen. Jedes Regelarmaturpaket wird vor der Auslieferung vollständig evaluiert und gemäß IEC 60534-2-1 für Dimensionierung, IEC 60534-8-3 und IEC 60534-8-4 für Geräuschberechnungen getestet, damit die Installation, die Inbetriebnahme und der Betrieb einfach und problemlos verläuft. Wir bei Bray sind stolz darauf, Qualitätsprodukte für all Ihre Branchenanforderungen zu produzieren. Unser Antrieb und unser Engagement für Kundenzufriedenheit haben Bray International zu einem der innovativsten Armaturenhersteller der Welt gemacht.
Mehr Bray-Einblicke
Erfahren Sie mehr darüber, wie die Lösungen von Bray Ihr Unternehmen unterstützen können
Vertrauen Sie bei Regelarmaturen auf das Expertenteam von Bray
Regelarmatur-Auslegung
Brays Erfahrung bei der Auslegung von Regelarmaturen stellt sicher, dass unsere Regelventilpakete für Ihre Prozessbedingungen optimiert sind und Ihr Geschäftsergebnis verbessern.
Mehr erfahren
